Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Half Way Point

Let's put Matthew Stafford's Dr. Jekkyle and Mr. Hyde performance into a little perspective. First, let's look at our good friend Joey Harrington. Joey failed in the NFL because he is a poor leader and was timid on the field. It didn't matter how many yards the Lions needed on 3rd down, Joey always checked down to the route that was run 2 yards shorter than the first down marker. Joey's not stupid, he just played scared and instead of trying to make a play for the first down, he'd take the easy completition that never resulted in a first down. He was scared to take chances and was more scared of being embarassed going down the field than giving his team a chance to win.

4 of the 5 interceptions Stafford threw were in third and long situations. I'm not trying to make excuses, I'm not trying to defend Stafford's poor choices on all 5 of those throws, I'm not saying that we shouldn't be concerned about Stafford. What I am saying is that I'd rather have a quarterback that is out there trying to win games than a quarterback playing scared, just checking down. When the Schwartz made the decision to put a rookie quarterback in the starting role, we knew that there was going to be growing pains. This year is a wash anyway, we all knew no playoffs were coming. Hopefully Stafford got this game out of his system and he can learn from his play and never do it again. Anyone saying that Stafford is a bust because of this game needs mental health. I'm not saying he's going to be Peyton Manning, but his statistics through 8 games of Peyton's rookie year are nearly identical and Peyton threw one 5 interception game in his career, it also was in his rookie season and he never did it again.

From comparing the game tape to the Week 3 game tape, I really think Stafford's knee is not in as good of shape as we thought it was. Stafford hasn't been accurate yet this year, but prior to these past two weeks, he's been missing long, often putting too much into his throws. Yet, each of his 5 interceptions against the Hawks were underthrown balls. In the Redskins tape, Stafford's mechanics looked great, he was getting depth and throwing in rhythm. Last week, he didn't have any trouble getting depth, but despite having all the time in the world (at least in Lion's terms) he wasn't putting much weight on his back foot, instead he was throwing off of his front foot. It's often said that receivers throw with their legs and all the leverage in deep balls come from the back foot. Further proof, Stafford was again limited in practice on Wednesday. Without the deep ball, the offense is going to continue to struggle in the later half of games.

FIRST HALF LIONS MVP:
One of the reasons this blog was started was to discuss football. Not what players are doing off the field, whether the guys are getting along in the lockerroom, this blog was started to discuss football in the trenches and break down the play on the field. You hear the them say that the "football is won in the trenches" yet the mainstream media continues to be infatuated with the skill positions and never discusses the play of the lineman. It boggles my mind that Stephen Peterman has received no credit for the performance that he has put together the first half of the season. Peterman, without a doubt, has been the Lions first half MVP. Last year, playing in only 13 games, Peterman gave up 3 sacks and 24 quarterback pressures in passing protection and was a poor run blocker. This year, in 8 games, he's given up 1 sack and only 3 quarterback pressures in the passing game and has been dominating his opponents (including the Williams wall, Haynesworth, the Steel curtain). Last year Peterman had trouble holding onto the right guard position, this year he his numbers are pro-bowl worthy, not that he'll get any real consideration since he plays for the Lie-downs. I'd argue that he is the most improved player in the entire NFL.

I wish I had access to the players like the media does. That's why I don't break the latest Lions news, or report what's going on at practices. The beat-writers do a good job of that, and I don't have access to the facilities or the players like they do. What I can do is break down the tape and let you know how the players are doing. I wish I could sit down with Peterman and give him the credit he deserves. I want to know what Peterman did in the offseason to turn his game around. Is it the difference in the scheme, did he work with a specific trainer, does he dedicate more time to film study? Peterman's performance merits credit from the beat writers. There's a story here that they are missing, and that Lions fans would love to hear.

The Lions offensive line will always get dogged by the fans, but whether he continues to get no credit for it or not, it's nice to have a lineman that is capable of dominating his opponents on a weekly basis.

Thursday, November 5, 2009

Week 9 Preview: Lions @ Seahawks

It's time to forget about last week and look ahead. Calvin's practiced both Wednesday and Thursday, he should play, and he needs to rejuvenate this Lion offense. From a statistical stand point, the Lions and Seahawks are putting up very similar numbers. The Lions are converting 39.6% of third downs, Seahawks 37%. Lions defense is allowing 36.8% of third down conversions, the Seahawks 38.3%. Each team has reached the redzone 17 times converting 8 of their opportunities into touchdowns. In terms of yards the Lions offense is ranked 25, the Seahawks 22. On defense Lions are ranked 23, Seattle 14. Those statistics are good indicators of trends, but mean virtually nothing considering your team plays a different opponent with different tendencies each and every week. So let's get into the real analysis.

RUSHING OFFENSE:
The Seahawks have shut down Stephen Jackson and Maurice Jones-Drew, holding them to 67 and 34 yards respectively, in games this year. They also allowed Gore to run for 207 yards in Week 2 this year. Their rushing defense is good, the 49ers game was a fluke. The defensive lineman are extremely good at holding up offensive lineman and not allowing them to get to the Seahawk linebackers. The Seahawk linebackers are very good; they fly to the ball, make good reads and are sure tacklers. In Week 2, the 49ers offensive line did an excellent job getting to the linebackers with mis-direction run plays that take some time to develop. Once Gore got through the first line, he exposed the secondary. Gore had a touchdown run of 80 yards and 78 yards, on both runs, the safeties were unable to make tackles. If the Lions offensive line is able to open a big hole, Kevin Smith could break a huge touchdown run, but this defensive line is very good and it's unlikely to see one-on-one with a safety. The key to this game is going to be the offensive line sustaining their blocks so that Smith will be able to cut back against the flow of the linebackers. It's going to be a tough task to accomplish. On a personal note (there is no analysis behind this comment which I dedicated this blog to), Kevin Smith needs to have a huge day. After a terrible game against an extremely vulnerable Rmas team, it is critical that Smith shows something or else the coaching staff really needs to start considering new options for the future at the runningback position.

LIONS PASSING OFFENSE:
Calvin can have a big day against this secondary. Ken Lucas was brought in to headline the pass defense, but he has not been having a good year. The Lions need to test Lucas, Linehan needs to stretch the field sending Calvin deep and take some chances with him. For the past two games, Northcutt has been forced to transition to an outside receiver. With Calvin stretching the field, they need to get Northcutt back into the slot roll and call the short routes to him on a constant basis. The Lions are going to have a difficult time running against this defense, to take advantage of the Seahawks double covering Calvin, the Lions need to get the ball in Northcutts hands over the middle for short gains to eventually open up the long ball.

RUSHING DEFENSE:
The Seahawks offensive line is very good at pass blocking and very poor at run blocking. The front seven is going to need to be very disciplined about clogging holes and not letting Jones bounce it outside. Over and over again we've seen that the Lions corners are incapable of taking the correct angle and making the tackles when running backs bounce what looks like minimal gains to the outside. The corners cannot be counted on. Jones isn't a monster of a runner like Jackson, so the Lions should be able to shut down the runs up the middle, but the Foote, Sims, Peterson and Levy are going to need to do a good job of reading the running back and reading the hole that the running back is going to run through and meet them there so that the running back can't bounce it outside.

PASSING DEFENSE:
Hasselback is a very smart quarterback; he makes good reads, few mistakes, and rarely takes sacks. He really is one of the best at his position in the league, though no one gives him credit for it. The one thing that Hasselback struggles with is the deep ball. This year he is 1-11 with an interception on balls thrown over 20 yards. I'll be captain obvious for a moment and make the statement that the Lions secondary is not very good. The secondary needs to be aggressive in stopping the shorter routes and take their chances with being vulnerable for the long ball. The Seahawk receivers are pretty good and it's going to be a mismatch no matter what they do. The secondary might as well try to take away Hasselback's strength and force him to do what he hasn't proven he's been able to do yet this year if they want a chance at winning this game. Another key is going to be tackling Nate Buerleson after he catches the ball. Buerleson is explosive in the open field and he's been burning corners all year in on-one-one situations.

OVERVIEW:
The Lions need to bounce back this week in a big way. Qwest field is known as the hardest place for a visiting team to play and a win is very improbable, especially considering how underrated Hasselback is. The Lions don't necessarily need to win this game, but they need to take a huge step in the right direction. Smith needs to prove that he is the running back of the future and Schwartz needs to prove that he is the right man for the job. Despite the embarrassment last week, and the slight loss in faith in the coaching staff, I still believe in the Schwartz. If this game wasn't in Seattle, I would pick the Lions to win. Since it is, I'm picking a close loss, with the Lions showing us that they are very much alive and back on track moving in the right direction.

Tuesday, November 3, 2009

Week 8 Recap: Here we go again...

I was wrong. I said it in the last column and I'll say it again, the only thing you can count on from the Lions, is when hope starts to build, the Lions let you down. The more good they show, the higher the hope-a-meter gets, the harder they let you down. I thought they were building, I was wrong.

I thought the Schwartz leadership would prevent this team from playing below their capabilities. I was wrong. I gave the Schwartz a pass after the embarrassing loss that I traveled 10 hours to watch at Lambeau. I was wrong to give them the pass because they had 6 starters our with injuries.

I started this blog because the Lions were heading in the right direction. I was wrong. I told myself I wouldn't start putting time and effort into this team until I knew that management was taking this team down the right road. I was wrong. I was wrong, I was wrong, I was wrong, wrong, wrong.

You can't judge a team by one game, especially a bad team that is trying to build. The Detroit fans are blowing up right now, and rightly so after such a poor outing. But so many voices out there have unrealistic expectations for this team. Anyone that thought this team would win more than 5 games this year is insane. With that said, a successful season is going to be measured by the progress and development that this team makes from Week 1 to Week 17. By those measures, a Week 8 loss to the Rams doesn't mean that the season is lost. That's the good news.

The bad news is that the Lions have haven't only digressed in the past two weeks, they've only exposed more holes in the already porous team. No wide receivers had catches during the first three quarters of the game. I counted 8 drops, 4 coming from wide receivers in the game. Bryant Johnson and Dennis Northcutt were exposed as players that need to be upgraded in order for the Lions to have a running game. The few times that Derrick Williams was on the field, he was unable to get open only getting one target from Stafford all game. The offensive line did a good job getting a push on the Rams defensive line. They were opening up holes, which doesn't say much because every team pushes the Rams around, but Smith had trouble getting through the holes. On the second play of the game, the line opened up a huge hole setting up Smith to go one-on-one with the safety for a touchdown, but Smith tripped over Chris Long's flailing arm (Long was laid out on the ground) while going through the hole and could only fall forward for a three yard gain. Maurice Morris did a good job getting through the holes, but he has no explosion once he gets through the first line. Morris is a good change of pace, but I'm now convinced that the Lions don't have a true number one running back. The offensive line is better than they are credited with, but with the exception of Stephen Peterman, no one is well above average.

Before this game, I thought the Lions could address some of their secondary and defensive end positions and get an upgrade on the offensive line and really compete next year. Now, beyond their desperate defensive needs, it looks like they need a bunch of offensive skill positioned players as well. It's looking like success next year is going to be measured in the same way as this year: how much progress have they made from Week 1 to Week 17. Then hopefully they can be competitive in '11 and be playing for the play offs in '12.

GAME ANALYSIS:
The Lions opened up the game pounding the rock running 5 straight running plays for 24 yards. What a solid game plan to start the game. They did a great job establishing the run and setting up for a long pass. On the sixth run in a row, the Lions were flagged for holding. On third and long, the Lions proved that they didn't need to establish the run to go deep on the Rams secondary when Bryant Johnson got wide open on a deep fly pattern... and dropped the ball. The Lions were forced to punt.

Throughout the entire game the Lions did a good job running the ball. With the exception of two holding calls in a row on the last series, essentially killing any chance of a come back for the Lions, Jansen was an upgrade at the left guard position. The Lions consistently ran it behind him and he was blowing away the defensive tackles. The Lions effective running game had the deep ball set up all game, yet Linehan never dialed it up. I don't understand why he wouldn't go deep, he must have been concerned that the receivers wouldn't be able to pull the ball in. No team has given up more long balls in the NFL than the Rams, the Lions proved they could get open deep even when the Rams were looking for a deep pass and the Lions were running the ball effectively... All the opportunities were there, I don't get it. Linehan's game calling was inexcusable.

Stafford was getting a lot of grief, but he really didn't play bad. He wasn't always accurate, but he hasn't been all year. His one interception was off a dropped pass by Aaron Brown. He's a rookie and I don't want to use that as an excuse for him, but look at Peyton Manning or Drew Brees' games when they were rookies, they weren't that accurate either. Quarterbacks take time to learn how to play at professional level, he was making good decisions. He needs to be more accurate, but there should be no concerns with Stafford.

The defense is bad, and that shouldn't surprise anyone. They played well enough to win the game, this loss is solely on the offense. For the first three quarters, the Lions did a good job of shutting down Jackson. In the 4th Jackson had 92 yards including the 25 yard TD run. On the score, Cliff Avril crashed in, Jackson bounced outside, a pulling guard blocked Simms out and in a one-on-one situation Delmas took a bad angle and couldn't make the tackle. Although Delmas took the bad angle, the score is really on Avril. The Rams had just got into field goal range and wanted to run down the clock since there was 2 minutes and some change left. Everyone knew it was going to be a run play and for some reason, Avril rushed hard trying to get down field like it was a pass. He needs to realize the situation he's in and create a pile so the linebackers have a chance at the tackle.

The Rams offensive line is pretty terrible, yet the Lions were not only unable to get a sack, they were unable to even get a hit on Bulger. I think that's even more embarrassing than 8 dropped balls (though less surprising). So much for dialing up effective blitzes.

On the same note, you have to give props to the secondary on doing a good job with the receivers. Despite not being touched the entire game, Bulger only had a 51.6 passer rating. The Lions didn't give up any deep balls all game and Delmas made McMichael pay every time he tried to come across the middle. Unfortunately, the Rams were able to complete passes when they needed them the most, including three huge passes during their game winning final drive.

WEEK 8 OVERVIEW:
I had totally bought in on the coaching staff. Prior to Week 8, their game planning was playing second to none and they had the team playing better than the talent they were putting out on the field. This week, from the ineffective blitz calls, to the unwillingness to stretch the field, to not preparing the team for a fake fieldgoal from a desperate team at a desperate time, the Lions coaching staff has all of Detroit second guessing. And worst of all, this coming off of the Lions bye week against arguably the worst team in the NFL.